Buy cheap, buy adjustable, and expect the first one to be wrong. That’s the honest summary, and it would have saved us about eighty pounds and a fortnight of frustration if anyone had said it to me at the start.
We went the other way. I ordered something expensive and custom because it seemed like the serious choice, and it sat in a drawer for three weeks while we worked out that it didn’t fit and we didn’t yet know what we wanted. If you’re at the point of actually buying something, here’s what I wish I’d known.
Why the First One Is Practice
The first device isn’t the device you’ll settle on. It’s the one that teaches you what to look for — whether he needs more room, whether the ring size is right, whether he can sleep in it, whether either of you actually enjoys the thing once it’s real rather than theoretical.
Insight: Treat the first purchase as a fitting, not a commitment. Couples who spend heavily up front tend to feel obliged to persist with something uncomfortable, and discomfort is the main reason people abandon this in the first month.
Spend little. Learn fast. Buy properly the second time.
What Actually Matters
Most of the specifications you’ll see listed are noise. Four things aren’t.
1. Ring Size Above Everything
This is the single decision that determines whether it works. Too tight and it’s painful within hours; too loose and it simply comes off. Most starter kits ship with three or four rings for exactly this reason — buy one that does, and expect to try each of them.
2. Adjustable Beats Custom
A cheap adjustable kit tells you your measurements. A custom piece assumes you already know them. Get the information first.
3. Material, and Being Honest About Wear Time
Plastic and silicone are lighter, cheaper, more forgiving, and fine for evenings and overnight. Metal is heavier and more durable but far less forgiving of a wrong fit. For a first device, lighter is the safer answer.
4. Whether He Can Actually Sleep in It
A device that works for an evening and not for a night limits you to short lock-ups. Worth knowing before you plan anything longer — and worth testing deliberately rather than discovering at three in the morning.
The Conversation to Have Before You Order
Agree two things in advance, because both are much harder to raise once money has been spent.
First, that he can say it isn’t working without it being a failure. “Tell me if it’s wrong and we’ll try something else” costs you nothing and removes his main reason to grit his teeth through something that hurts.
Second, how you’ll handle the practical side — cleaning, time out of it, what happens if something feels off. None of that is romantic, and all of it decides whether you’re still doing this in three months.
Start Smaller Than You Think
Ours took three attempts before we found something he could actually forget he was wearing, which turns out to be the whole point. You’ll get there faster by spending less at the start. If you haven’t settled on how long a first lock-up should run, I’ve written about that separately, and if you’re still deciding whether to try any of this, start here instead. What tripped you up on your first one? Share below. For a head start, grab my free Top 10 Trust-Building Tips for Couples—it’s yours the moment you subscribe.